16 Valentine's Day Gifts for Your Christian Boyfriend

Valentine’s Day is one of those holidays where you’re expected to walk into a store, grab some chocolate, and grab a card that says, “I love you”—but doesn’t that feel too easy? If your boyfriend’s faith is important to him and you both want to get deeper than the typical “roses and teddy bears” cliché, why not use this as a chance to give something unique, meaningful, and yes, even a little quirky?

The truth is, a gift that’s a little bit strange but still comes from your heart will probably stick in his memory longer. Plus, if you center it on his faith and what makes him, him, it shows you see him deeply—that’s a pretty big deal.

So, whether it makes him stop and laugh or just say, “Wow, this is different,” let’s dive into ideas that hit somewhere between surprising and sentimental.

Table of Contents

1. Custom Prayer Jar for Him and You

A prayer jar might not sound like a traditional Valentine’s Day gift—but that’s what’s so beautiful about it. It’s heartfelt, it’s personal, and it’s a reminder of faith and connection.

What makes it special?

You can personalize a mason jar or small decorative box. Label it something like “Our Prayer Jar” or “His (and Hers) Prayers”.
Include tiny handwritten prayer requests or Bible verses that resonate with him.
Want to get creative? Add reasons you’ve prayed for him in the past or prayers about your future together. You could even throw in a few inside jokes for lighthearted moments.

He can use it as a daily reminder of God’s promises, while also cherishing the thought you put into it. It’s unique, and it doubles as an ongoing way you both can connect through faith.

A beautifully decorated mason jar labeled "Our Prayer Jar," surrounded by tiny handwritten notes with prayers, Bible verses, and lighthearted doodles. The jar is set on a wooden table, with soft warm lighting and a Bible in the background.

Read: Bible Verses for Christian Wedding Anniversary

2. A Funny “Jesus Took the Wheel” Car Decal

Humor with a side of spirituality? Yes, please. If your boyfriend has a car, think about gifting him a funny-yet-meaningful decal or bumper sticker like, “Jesus Took the Wheel (But I’m Navigating)”.

Why it works:

It’s practical, but still a lighthearted nod to his faith.
Every time he gets in the car, he’ll have something that reminds him of two things: his relationship with God and your quirky sense of humor.

You could even go for humor tailored to his personality. Is he into fishing? Go for “Becoming a Fisher of Men Full-Time”. Into sports? Maybe something like, “Powered by Christ, Fueled by Caffeine, Coached by Grace.”

Trust me, he’ll get a kick out of it—and isn’t laughter one of the purest forms of love?

3. A Personalized Bible Cover with a Twist

Here’s where you can blend practicality with intentionality. But instead of giving him just any generic leather Bible cover, go for something that reflects a little more personality. Jazz it up with some humor or design elements.

Ideas to consider:

Find a company that can engrave his name and a quote or reference meaningful to your relationship, like “1 Corinthians 13” or “Jeremiah 29:11.”
Add an unexpected detail that makes it so him. Is he quirky? Throw in a cartoonish fish or a little cross-doodle. Loves music? Add a guitar engraved alongside his name.

If he already has his heart set on his Bible looking its original way, you could grab a clutch-size notebook with the same vibe instead and pair it with a fancy pen. That way, he hangs onto something that mirrors his love for scripture but with a fun flourish.

4. His Very Own “Christian Boyfriend Survival Kit”

You’ve heard of “emergency kits.” What about a completely off-the-wall version tailored just for him? This takes creativity to another level.

What goes inside?

Something funny: Bible-themed socks (like ones that say “Holy Sole”), a gag rosary, or “Test Your Bible Knowledge” trivia cards.
Something practical: A small devotional book or a list of your favorite scripture recommendations.
Something sweet: A mini jar of honey with a playful note—like “Sweeter Than Honey, Just Like Psalm 119:103.”
Something cheesy: Add a note that says “In case of spiritual emergencies, I’ll be praying for you.”

The beauty of a kit is you can make it what you want—funny, faith-centered, or super sentimental. (And yes, adding snacks is always encouraged!)

Read: Unveiling the Perfect Personalized Christian Wedding Gifts

5. Christian-Themed Matching T-Shirts or Sweaters

Some people roll their eyes at couple-matching gear. But hear me out—when they’re subtle and fun, it’s actually adorable.

Thoughtful ideas:

Shirts that play off scripture. For example, yours could say “Proverbs 31: Woman” and his could say “Ephesians 5: Husb… One Day.”
If you want something playful, go for a joke like “God’s Plan > My Plans” or “Fueled by Prayer and Pizza (Together).”

It’s great for casual days, and it’s one of those gifts that’s just goofy enough to be unforgettable.

6. A Faith-Filled Adventure Map

If your boyfriend loves traveling—or even if he’s got the smallest spark of wanderlust—this could be something special. Imagine giving him a scratch-off adventure map, but customized to reflect faith-based landmarks.

How to create it:

Use a blank map and mark locations that hold spiritual significance. Examples: local churches, mission-based organizations, or even nature trails where he feels closest to God.
Add notes or “dates” below every location. Write something like “Let’s visit together” or “Time to reflect on this journey.”

It’s about sharing experiences while gifting something that acknowledges both his love for adventure and his belief in God.

7. Crosswork Puzzles (Crossword + Faith)

If he’s the type who loves puzzles or mind games, why not create a Valentine’s-themed Bible crossword? Include things about your relationship alongside faith-related clues.

Ideas to make it fun:

Clues like “Her eyes remind me of Song of Songs 4:1” or “Our first verse as a couple.”
Mix in scriptures, inside jokes, or his favorite Christian musicians or preachers as answers.

He’s not just solving a puzzle—he’s unlocking memories and spiritual reminders.

8. A “Fruit of the Spirit” Snack Basket

What’s better than snacks? Snacks that have a deeper meaning. This gift idea takes Galatians 5:22-23 (“the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, patience…”) and brings it to life in a fun, edible way.

Here’s how you can put it together:

Fill a cute basket or box with snacks or items representing each “fruit.” For example:
- Love: Chocolate hearts or anything he loves to eat.
- Joy: A bright-colored treat (yellow candy or anything cheerful-looking).
- Peace: Chamomile tea or a tiny prayer candle.
- Patience: Chewing gum (because patience = chewing through something for a while!).
- Kindness: A handwritten note or something sweet to make him smile.
- Goodness: Fresh fruit or organic snacks.
- Self-Control: His favorite snack, but sealed with a funny note saying “Don’t eat all at once!”

You can even add scripture references or silly notes with each item to make it more personal. It’s symbolic and tasty, which is a win-win.

Read: Top Gifts For Your Christian Boyfriend

9. A Quirky Christian Meme Book

If your guy loves memes and has a solid sense of humor about his faith, this is a hilarious yet thoughtful gift. You can easily DIY this by creating a little booklet or printing out pages of Christian-themed memes.

Ideas for content to include:

Memes about Bible verses (like the one about Jonah definitely needing therapy after the whale situation).
Jokes about Sunday mornings (coffee-fueled worship, anyone?).
Humor about love in the Bible (Canal of Honey? That’s a Song of Songs level compliment).

Take it a step further by adding personal captions: “This made me think of you because _.” Every page will feel tailored to his personality and give him laughs, which is honestly the best combo.

10. Faith-Inspired Comic Strip Starring Him

This one’s such a fun, personal gift—perfect if he has a goofy, lighthearted side. You basically create a mini comic strip that blends Christian themes with your life together. And no, you don’t need to be an amazing artist for this. Stick figures work just fine.

How to create it:

Use paper or even design it online, and make him the star of the comic.
Add faith-based humor—like him as a modern-day David slaying his daily “giants” (work stress, long lines at Chick-fil-A, etc.), with you as his helper.
Connect the story back to scriptures or values you both share.

It’s thoughtful, personal, and one-of-a-kind—he’s guaranteed to never have gotten a gift like this before!

11. A Customized Hymnal Notebook

Does he love worship music? Is there a song or hymn that means a lot to him? You can create a simple, heartfelt gift by upcycling an old hymnal or designing a notebook inspired by his favorite worship songs.

Here’s the plan:

Take an old or thrifted hymnal and transform it into a notebook or journal cover. Use the music from his favorite hymn as decoration.
Personalize the pages. Add Bible verse stickers, journaling prompts, or love notes to remind him of both his faith and your relationship.

The best part? Every time he writes in it, he’ll be reminded of this special, thoughtful gift.

12. Christian-Themed Board Game Night Kit

If you’re looking to spend quality time together this Valentine’s Day, why not gift him something playful like a faith-inspired game night kit? Think outside the box—literally—and find games that connect to scripture or spiritual learning.

What might this include?

A Bible board game like “Bibleopoly” (come on, that’s perfect for laughs).
Trivia cards with silly prizes for answering scripture questions (think gummy bears or sweet notes).
Or you can DIY—create your own Jenga-inspired game with little faith-based questions or tasks written on each block:
- Example: “Name 3 Bible verses on love,” or “Pray for someone on your left.”

It’s interactive, unique, and a chance to bond over fun and faith.

Read: Do It Yourself Presents for Christian Boyfriend

13. “Faithflix” Movie Night Basket

Who doesn’t love a cozy night in? Christian movie night baskets are popular, sure—but making it quirky and tailored to him is where the magic happens.

What to include:

A mix of romantic, faith-centered movies (Fireproof, The Case for Christ, or even the Chosen series).
Fun snacks (think popcorn with a pun like “Holy kernels, it’s date night!”).
Cozy extras, like socks with a Bible verse on them.

You could also sneak in a short love letter, where you talk about how his faith inspires you… because honestly, everyone deserves that kind of encouragement.

14. A Subscription to a Faith-Based Coffee Club

Okay, this gift goes out to the caffeine-loving boyfriend who sees his morning cup as basically Jesus juice. Did you know there are Christian-owned coffee subscription services that give back to missions or ministries?

Here’s why this is a great pick:

He gets to enjoy amazing coffee (win!).
It also helps support causes rooted in faith.
For extra fun, you can include a mug with a cheeky message like “Fueled by Jesus and Java”.

It’s strange in the sense that most people don’t think of coffee subscriptions as romantic Valentine’s gifts—but for the right guy? It’s spot on.

Read: Top 10 Gifts For Your Christian Girlfriend

15. Personalized “Faith Adventures” Date Cards

Want to plan future dates but keep them faith-focused and fun? Create a set of DIY faith-inspired date cards where you suggest things for you two to do together—stuff he wouldn’t expect.

Ideas for your cards:

Attend another church’s worship service together.
Visit a Christian bookstore and pick out a devotional for each other.
Volunteer at a local charity or food bank.
Go on a nature walk where you take turns pointing out things that make you think of God’s creation.

Add these to a small box or envelope set and label it like “15 Adventures with God and You.” It’s creative, it keeps your faith at the center, and it’s a gift that extends far beyond February 14th.

Read: “Will You Be My Valentine?” Ideas That You’ll Love

16. A “Christ-Like Compliments” Jar

What if you spent Valentine’s Day focusing on building him up with a gift that speaks to his character? Create a jar (or even a stack of notes) filled with affirmations rooted in faith.

What to write on the notes:

Compliments based on his integrity, kindness, or relationship with God.
Share verses that make you think of him, such as Proverbs 27:17 (“As iron sharpens iron, so one person sharpens another.”).
Add some silly ones too—like “If you were one of the disciples, you’d definitely walk on water.”

These kinds of gifts carry so much heart, and it gives him a little love to look at whenever he needs encouragement.